NWID holds special meeting to discuss future of ACR
With two deadlines looming that will determine if the Alkali Creek Reservoir Project goes forward or how it will go forward, three of five property owners expressed interest in negotiating agreements for easements.
During a special meeting in Hyattville across from the post office last Wednesday, the board first elected new officers with Martin Mercer, current chairman, being unseated in the November General Election.
John Joyce was elected chairman, Terri O’Donnell as vice chairman, newly elected board member Todd Jones as secretary and Sherri Mascaro as treasurer.
Discussion then turned to the topic of five outstanding easements necessary for the project to move forward. During the meeting Joyce mentioned two deadlines, one is Monday, Dec. 7, when there will be a hearing on the eminent domain filings in Big Horn County District Court in Basin.
There were questions about who was pushing eminent domain and the board said the easement agreements do not mention eminent domain or land condemnation, that decision came from the NWID board. Mascaro noted that the decision did not come lightly.
The second deadline is Dec. 17, the next meeting of the Wyoming Legislature’s Select Water Committee and the Wyoming Water Development Commission.
In a story by Angus M. Thuermer Jr. of WyoFile, “state officials asked Nowood Watershed Improvement District and five area landowners to further negotiate over necessary easements and avoid the water district’s taking of private property.”
Joyce said in the beginning they sent out letters to all landowners where they would need easements and eventually “the state decided to do the negotiations.”
During the nearly hour-long discussion at last week’s special meeting, landowners expressed frustration with the lack of communication from the board.
The landowners still needing easements are Diamond S Ranch LLC, Paul R. Hughes and Kathy Karlenzig-Hughes, Thomas N. Searfoss, George Thomas Shirran Revocable Trust and Hamilton Ranch Inc.
In addressing a question why the easements weren’t the first thing to be obtained, even before the land was purchased, Joyce said permits for the Army Corps of Engineers, Bureau of Reclamation and Bureau of Land Management were required first.
They board did obtain several easements from landowners including one Caines family, Security State Bank, Hermanns and Paintrock Angus.
Joyce said initially the Hamiltons had a set a meeting with the board that was to take place prior to the special meeting but it was canceled with the Hamiltons asking the board to negotiate with their attorney.
Tom Searfoss said he would be willing to negotiate but advised the board to contact his attorney as well.
Paul Hughes said he did not feel that he could negotiate with the board following the last offer, noting it felt like a “take it or leave it” offer. He said, “If I had known I could have called you guys, I would have done so immediately. So now that I know, I’ll reach out. I have I have all of you guys’ email. I’ll reach out.”
Joyce said, “Right now our plan is to get everybody contacted, and again, and see if we can get some type of meetings put together and discussions. I understand it’s dragged out for five years now. A lot of people are very upset over it, and don’t want to talk about it. And if they don’t want to talk about it, that’s fine. We’ve realized that if we don’t have easements in place, they’ll pull the funding, and the project will be over. So, we’re moving ahead, trying to get easements put in place one way or the other.”
He added, “We’re at the point where we’d like to talk to anybody who would like to talk to us and try to get something worked out. There’s a lot of stuff, water under the bridge, and there’s lots of reasons for people to be upset. I understand that on both sides. If you want to dwell on that, please do. If you would like to move ahead with something different, that’s what we would prefer.”
Tom Shirran said that while he had issues and concerns about the proposed easement and documentation, “as far as I’m concerned that’s water under the bridge anyway. On the slate today is what we need to be dealing with and not the past. I am willing to negotiate.”
OTHER BUSINESS
In other business at the special meeting:
•Mascaro also offered a word of thanks to Mercer’s service, “for the work that you have put in, and understand that we appreciate the time that you had to put into this and the dedication. I know that not everyone sees eye to eye, but they also don’t know how much work being the chairman of this board requires. So, as a board member, I would ask that we all give him a vote of thanks.”
O’Donnell added that Mercer was one of the original members of the steering committee that has helped move the project forward.
Mercer said, “Appreciate the honor of being able to serve on it, and look forward to this thing. In my opinion, It’s hard, but I had a long talk with Todd Jones right there this morning about we can let this funding go away and this proposed reservoir not come to fruition, and we’re going to be in the same position of being short on water. In my mind, it would be very beneficial to every person standing here, every person in the state, every person in the United States, and every person in the world. Water is what it takes. I would pray that people would realize that more water will create more benefits and more avenues of being able to run your ranches or, you know even if you live right here in town, nothing worse than turning your spigot on or your head gate on and being short of water. And I think if you view it in that light and you do your research on Wyoming water law, Wyoming water rights, how the water rights are here in this valley, that it becomes perfectly clear, this project is highly beneficial, and maybe that everybody agrees with that. But we have to get serious and roll up our sleeves and figure out how we’re going to make the things come together.
“Maybe we didn’t have enough conversations, but God dang it! It sure appears to me that we’ve tried. Put something out there and get your back into it and try to come to a term that both people can sign. You know, the fact of the matter is, is you guys can sign your easement, but it has to be reasonable enough for the other people to sign as well. So, thank you so much, appreciate it and good luck to you guys.”
•Jones had offered to be the vice chairman and Mascaro said as secretary it was a great role for her to become acquainted with all things about the district.
•Cathy Caines asked how she could get out of the district and was informed it would require a petition to change the district boundary, which would then involve a special election.
•There was discussion on whether the Anita Ditch for the reservoir would remain an open ditch or pipe. The board said it would depend on funding from the state.
The Select Water Committee has halted any recommendation for an additional $44 million for the project, awaiting easement agreements. The Wyoming Legislature has approved $59 million for the project.
•It was noted that if the reservoir project falls through the land sold by Paintrock Angus would be resold and the money would be returned to the state.
By KARLA POMEROY
Northern Wyoming news
With two deadlines looming that will determine if the Alkali Creek Reservoir Project goes forward or how it will go forward, three of five property owners expressed interest in negotiating agreements for easements.
During a special meeting in Hyattville across from the post office last Wednesday, the board first elected new officers with Martin Mercer, current chairman, being unseated in the November General Election.
John Joyce was elected chairman, Terri O’Donnell as vice chairman, newly elected board member Todd Jones as secretary and Sherri Mascaro as treasurer.
Discussion then turned to the topic of five outstanding easements necessary for the project to move forward. During the meeting Joyce mentioned two deadlines, one is Monday, Dec. 7, when there will be a hearing on the eminent domain filings in Big Horn County District Court in Basin.
There were questions about who was pushing eminent domain and the board said the easement agreements do not mention eminent domain or land condemnation, that decision came from the NWID board. Mascaro noted that the decision did not come lightly.
The second deadline is Dec. 17, the next meeting of the Wyoming Legislature’s Select Water Committee and the Wyoming Water Development Commission.
In a story by Angus M. Thuermer Jr. of WyoFile, “state officials asked Nowood Watershed Improvement District and five area landowners to further negotiate over necessary easements and avoid the water district’s taking of private property.”
Joyce said in the beginning they sent out letters to all landowners where they would need easements and eventually “the state decided to do the negotiations.”
During the nearly hour-long discussion at last week’s special meeting, landowners expressed frustration with the lack of communication from the board.
The landowners still needing easements are Diamond S Ranch LLC, Paul R. Hughes and Kathy Karlenzig-Hughes, Thomas N. Searfoss, George Thomas Shirran Revocable Trust and Hamilton Ranch Inc.
In addressing a question why the easements weren’t the first thing to be obtained, even before the land was purchased, Joyce said permits for the Army Corps of Engineers, Bureau of Reclamation and Bureau of Land Management were required first.
They board did obtain several easements from landowners including one Caines family, Security State Bank, Hermanns and Paintrock Angus.
Joyce said initially the Hamiltons had a set a meeting with the board that was to take place prior to the special meeting but it was canceled with the Hamiltons asking the board to negotiate with their attorney.
Tom Searfoss said he would be willing to negotiate but advised the board to contact his attorney as well.
Paul Hughes said he did not feel that he could negotiate with the board following the last offer, noting it felt like a “take it or leave it” offer. He said, “If I had known I could have called you guys, I would have done so immediately. So now that I know, I’ll reach out. I have I have all of you guys’ email. I’ll reach out.”
Joyce said, “Right now our plan is to get everybody contacted, and again, and see if we can get some type of meetings put together and discussions. I understand it’s dragged out for five years now. A lot of people are very upset over it, and don’t want to talk about it. And if they don’t want to talk about it, that’s fine. We’ve realized that if we don’t have easements in place, they’ll pull the funding, and the project will be over. So, we’re moving ahead, trying to get easements put in place one way or the other.”
He added, “We’re at the point where we’d like to talk to anybody who would like to talk to us and try to get something worked out. There’s a lot of stuff, water under the bridge, and there’s lots of reasons for people to be upset. I understand that on both sides. If you want to dwell on that, please do. If you would like to move ahead with something different, that’s what we would prefer.”
Tom Shirran said that while he had issues and concerns about the proposed easement and documentation, “as far as I’m concerned that’s water under the bridge anyway. On the slate today is what we need to be dealing with and not the past. I am willing to negotiate.”
OTHER BUSINESS
In other business at the special meeting:
•Mascaro also offered a word of thanks to Mercer’s service, “for the work that you have put in, and understand that we appreciate the time that you had to put into this and the dedication. I know that not everyone sees eye to eye, but they also don’t know how much work being the chairman of this board requires. So, as a board member, I would ask that we all give him a vote of thanks.”
O’Donnell added that Mercer was one of the original members of the steering committee that has helped move the project forward.
Mercer said, “Appreciate the honor of being able to serve on it, and look forward to this thing. In my opinion, It’s hard, but I had a long talk with Todd Jones right there this morning about we can let this funding go away and this proposed reservoir not come to fruition, and we’re going to be in the same position of being short on water. In my mind, it would be very beneficial to every person standing here, every person in the state, every person in the United States, and every person in the world. Water is what it takes. I would pray that people would realize that more water will create more benefits and more avenues of being able to run your ranches or, you know even if you live right here in town, nothing worse than turning your spigot on or your head gate on and being short of water. And I think if you view it in that light and you do your research on Wyoming water law, Wyoming water rights, how the water rights are here in this valley, that it becomes perfectly clear, this project is highly beneficial, and maybe that everybody agrees with that. But we have to get serious and roll up our sleeves and figure out how we’re going to make the things come together.
“Maybe we didn’t have enough conversations, but God dang it! It sure appears to me that we’ve tried. Put something out there and get your back into it and try to come to a term that both people can sign. You know, the fact of the matter is, is you guys can sign your easement, but it has to be reasonable enough for the other people to sign as well. So, thank you so much, appreciate it and good luck to you guys.”
•Jones had offered to be the vice chairman and Mascaro said as secretary it was a great role for her to become acquainted with all things about the district.
•Cathy Caines asked how she could get out of the district and was informed it would require a petition to change the district boundary, which would then involve a special election.
•There was discussion on whether the Anita Ditch for the reservoir would remain an open ditch or pipe. The board said it would depend on funding from the state.
The Select Water Committee has halted any recommendation for an additional $44 million for the project, awaiting easement agreements. The Wyoming Legislature has approved $59 million for the project.
•It was noted that if the reservoir project falls through the land sold by Paintrock Angus would be resold and the money would be returned to the state.



